Bills’ Draft Dilemma: Which Game-Changing Rookie Could Buffalo Land in Round 1?

The Buffalo Bills are entering the 2024 NFL Draft with one clear goal: find an instant-impact player who can push them closer to a Super Bowl. With key roster holes to fill, general manager Brandon Beane must decide whether to target offense or defense with their first-round pick. Here’s a deep dive into the top prospects that could be wearing Bills colors on draft night.

Top Contenders for the Bills’ No. 28 Pick

• Brian Thomas Jr. (WR, LSU): A 6'4" deep threat with elite speed, Thomas could be the missing piece in Buffalo’s passing attack.
• Xavier Worthy (WR, Texas): The record-breaking 4.21-speedster could revolutionize Josh Allen’s downfield options.
• Troy Fautanu (OL, Washington): A versatile lineman who could shore up protection or open running lanes.
• Cooper DeJean (CB, Iowa): A ball-hawking defensive back who fits Buffalo’s aggressive secondary mold.
• Jer'Zhan Newton (DT, Illinois): An interior disruptor who could boost the Bills’ pass rush.

The Critical Need: Wide Receiver vs. Defense

After Stefon Diggs’ departure, Buffalo’s WR corps lacks a true WR1. Thomas or Worthy could fill that void, but the defense—ranked 14th in points allowed—needs reinforcements too. DeJean or Newton would bolster a unit that collapsed in key moments last season.

1. Offensive Priority: Allen needs weapons. A burner like Worthy could stretch defenses.
2. Defensive Priority: The Chiefs exposed Buffalo’s secondary. A lockdown corner changes that.
3. Sleeper Pick: Don’t rule out an edge rusher if a top talent falls.

Draft Night Wild Cards

Beane is known for trading up for "his guy." If a prospect like Thomas starts slipping, Buffalo might package picks to jump the line. Conversely, moving back for extra Day 2 selections could address multiple needs.

What Do You Think?

• Should the Bills prioritize offense over defense after years of playoff shortcomings?
• Is trading up for a WR worth sacrificing future draft capital?
• Would you trust a rookie receiver to replace Diggs’ production immediately?
• Does Buffalo’s window close if they don’t draft a defensive star?